PMF vs RMF: Which Applies to Your Dam?
· Written by Robert Fortuin
South African dam safety practice checks a dam against two floods: a design flood its spillway must pass without damage, and an extreme flood the dam must survive without failing. The extreme flood is set in one of two ways. The Regional Maximum Flood (RMF) is an envelope over the largest floods recorded in the region. The Probable Maximum Flood (PMF) is the flood the largest physically possible storm would produce on the dam’s own catchment. SANCOLD’s guidelines express the extreme flood in both forms and scale each to the dam’s size and hazard rating, so the answer to “which applies?” starts with the dam’s classification.
Start a conversation
Tell us about your project
Facing a dam safety evaluation, or unsure which extreme flood your dam should be checked against? We do the RMF and PMF hydrology, route both through the reservoir and set out the basis a reviewer expects.
Reply within one business day
The two floods every dam is checked against
SANCOLD’s Guidelines on Safety in Relation to Floods (1991) set two flood conditions:
- The Recommended Design Discharge (RDD). The spillway passes it without damage to any of its components or to the dam, with the normal freeboard intact. It is a return-period flood, from the 1:20 to 1:50-year flood for a small low-hazard dam up to the 1:200-year flood for any large dam.
- The Safety Evaluation Discharge (SED) or Safety Evaluation Flood (SEF). The dam must survive it. The spillway and parts of the dam may be badly damaged, but the dam must not fail and release the reservoir. This is where the RMF and the PMF come in.
Size, hazard and category
Both floods follow from the dam’s size class and hazard rating. Size comes from the wall height: small is over 5 m and under 12 m, medium is 12 m to under 30 m, and large is 30 m or more. The hazard rating (low, significant or high) comes from the potential loss of life, economic loss and damage to resource quality if the dam failed, which usually takes a dam break study to establish. Together they give the dam’s Category (I, II or III) under the Dam Safety Regulations (GN R139 of 2012). The DWS Dam Safety Office has the final say on the classification.
Which applies: the SANCOLD table
| Size | Hazard | Category | Design flood (RDD) | Extreme flood, RMF basis (SED) | Extreme flood, PMF basis (SEF) |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Small | Low | I | 1:20 to 1:50-year | RMF− | 0.2 × PMF |
| Small | Significant | II | 1:100-year | RMF− | 0.5 × PMF |
| Small | High | II | 1:100-year | RMF | 0.7 × PMF |
| Medium | Low | II | 1:100-year | RMF− | 0.5 × PMF |
| Medium | Significant | II | 1:100-year | RMF | 0.7 × PMF |
| Medium | High | III | 1:200-year | RMF+ | PMF |
| Large | Low | III | 1:200-year | RMF | 0.7 × PMF |
| Large | Significant | III | 1:200-year | RMF+ | PMF |
| Large | High | III | 1:200-year | RMF+ | PMF |
RMF− and RMF+ mean the RMF of the K-value region one step lower or one step higher than the site’s own. The PMF fractions come from SANCOLD’s 1986 interim guidelines. The 1991 guidelines replaced that table with a rule: for medium and large high-hazard dams and large dams of significant hazard, the inflow is the full PMF, and for smaller or lower-hazard dams the PMF may be scaled down in proportion to the corresponding SED. The fractions in the table are the 1986 ones, and they give the full PMF in the same three cells the 1991 rule names.
The guidelines also say how deep the evaluation must go. A generalised evaluation is enough for a small low-hazard (Category I) dam and is the first screen for every other dam. For all new high-hazard dams, and for medium and large dams of significant hazard, a site-specific analysis is obligatory, and for that the guidelines recommend the PMF.
The Regional Maximum Flood (RMF)
The RMF comes from Kovács (1988), DWA Technical Report TR 137. Kovács took the largest flood peaks on record up to 1988, grouped them into regions, and drew an envelope curve over each region using the Francou-Rodier method. Each region has a K-value from 2.8 to 5.6; the higher the K, the larger the flood for the same catchment area. For a given catchment area and K-region, the RMF is a single peak discharge.
Three things to know when it is used for a dam:
- It is a peak, not a hydrograph. Routing the SED through the reservoir needs an assumed hydrograph shape and volume, and the routed water level depends on that volume as well as on the peak.
- It has no return period. It is an envelope of what has been observed, not a probability estimate. Kovács implied it was rarer than 1:200 years but did not model it.
- The regions have been revised. Floods since 1988 pushed K up in several regions, and Du Plessis and Masule (2023) published a new regionalisation with smaller regions. SANCOLD’s RMF− and RMF+ steps were written on the 1988 regions, so confirm which regionalisation the evaluation uses.
The RMF is also less reliable for small or mostly urban catchments. Our article on design flood estimation shows where it sits among the other methods.
The Probable Maximum Flood (PMF)
The PMF starts from the Probable Maximum Precipitation (PMP): the greatest depth of rain physically possible over the catchment for a given duration. In South Africa the procedure is set out in HRU Report 1/72, and Johnson and Smithers (2020) updated the 1-day PMP. The PMP storm is applied to the catchment in its most flood-producing state, and a hydrograph method turns it into an inflow flood. Unlike the RMF, the PMF is a full hydrograph, so its volume is known when it is routed through the reservoir.
Its weak points are the inputs. The HRU PMP curves rest on about 30 years of rainfall records (1932 to 1962), and the choice of catchment parameters and hydrograph method can spread PMF estimates for one site widely. A PMF study has to document those choices and test their sensitivity.
Why you compute both
The two bases can give different flows for the same dam. Görgens et al. (2007), in a Water Research Commission review of South African practice, also noted that scaling the RMF and PMF by category, as SANCOLD does, does not fit the probability theory used for other design floods. Good practice is to compute both, route both through the reservoir from full supply level, check the freeboard, and record which one was adopted and why. For a Category II or III dam, the approved professional person carrying out the dam safety evaluation makes that call and signs the report.
When to involve hydrology early
- Spillway capacity or freeboard looks marginal once blockage, debris or tailwater is considered.
- Development downstream is growing, which can raise the hazard rating and move the dam into a stricter row of the table.
- The dam’s role is changing, for example from temporary construction storage to permanent infrastructure.
- The catchment is ungauged, changing fast through mining, fire or urbanisation, or has upstream dams that control the inflow.
Hydrology decisions cascade into the spillway design, the freeboard and the operating rules. Left late, a change in classification can turn into a spillway upgrade.
What the evaluation package contains
- Classification: size, hazard and Category, agreed with the Dam Safety Office.
- Event definitions: the RDD return period, the SED and SEF bases from the table, and the flows adopted.
- Method statement: the RMF region and regionalisation used, the PMP source, losses, hydrograph method and key parameters.
- Routing and freeboard: both floods routed through the reservoir, with the maximum water levels and the freeboard check.
- Sensitivity: the few uncertain inputs that move the answer, and by how much.
Questions to ask your engineer
- Which size class, hazard rating and Category is the evaluation based on, and has the Dam Safety Office agreed it?
- Which RMF regionalisation was used, and which step of the table applies?
- Where did the PMP come from, and what hydrograph method turned it into the PMF?
- Which basis governs, and why was it adopted?
- What would trigger a re-run: new development downstream, a revised classification, or changes in the catchment?
This post summarises the SANCOLD guidelines as reproduced in the WRC report listed below. It is not a substitute for a dam safety evaluation by an approved professional person.
Documents referenced
Links go to official government copies wherever one is published online. Check for amendments before relying on a specific clause.
- Regulations regarding the safety of dams in terms of section 123(1) of the National Water ActRegulations · GN R139 of 2012 · Department of Water Affairs
- Modernised South African Design Flood Practice in the Context of Dam Safety (Görgens et al., 2007)Report · WRC Report 1420/2/07 · Water Research Commission
- Revised Regional Maximum Flood (RMF) method and regionalisation (Du Plessis and Masule, 2023)Report · Journal of the South African Institution of Civil Engineering
- A Guide to Flood Frequency Estimation Methods as applied in the DWS (July 2025)Guideline · Eleventh edition, version 2 · Department of Water and Sanitation
Start a conversation
Tell us about your project
Working on a site where flooding, stormwater, or floodlines are a concern? Send us a message about it and we’ll reply within one business day — no obligation.
Reply within one business day
